The Story of the Waterless Urinal – Hits and Misses

After being granted government approval, waterlessthe deposits. The university's janitors may not have
urinals from Falcon have found more than 200,000followed this procedure, but they cannot be blamed as
buyers and competitor companies have also croppedit is natural to assume that a waterless urinal may not
up. There is no disputing the environmental benefits ofrequire flushing with water.
waterless urinals, but one thing is certain - issues canIn other instances where Falcon's waterless urinals
arise if they are not maintained properly.missed the mark, Sacramento's EPA headquarters
University of Washington, Seattle conducted anreported clogged drain pipes, dirty bathrooms and a
experiment in 2007 to decide if they could go aheadbad smell. All the urinals here were removed in
with a mass purchase of Falcon's waterless urinals forFebruary this year. Other establishments that have
the entire college. They took the help of waterfaced such problems and subsequently uninstalled their
conservation consultant Roger van Gelder towaterless urinals include O'Hare International Airport
determine if such urinals could work in theirand Chicago City Hall. Chicago plumber Jim
environment.  For the purpose of the study, VanMajerowicz says that the requirement to plumb water
Gelder asked that the existing drain pipes be replacedto these urinals is a good idea, as the building owner
with newer pipes to start afresh. Six months into thedoes not have to drain his wallet when he gets the
study, Van Gelder had bad news to report. Afterwaterless urinals uninstalled.
opening the pipes, he discovered that some sort of oilyBut Falcon's waterless urinals have also found
liquid has started clogging the drain lines. It would beadmirers in many facilities across the United States,
matter of days before the lines would get completelyincluding Southern California's Temecula Valley School
blocked.District. Maintenance Operations Director at the facility
Another problem that Van Gelder found with Falcon'sGaylon Holland says that with good maintenance, the
waterless urinals was the plastic cartridges. Theywaterless urinals deliver first rate performance and
would get clogged faster than projected, in somesave large quantities of water. The facility has installed
cases after just above 600 uses and subsequentlymore than 600 Falcon urinals and the janitorial staff is
had to be recycled or disposed off. The disposal of asufficiently trained on how to maintain them. The Las
large quantity of plastic wasn't eco-friendly, ironic givenVegas Motor Speedway and Rose Bowl Stadium are
that the waterless urinal was inherently a greentwo other facilities where waterless urinals have
product. Besides the cartridges had to be replaceddelivered satisfactory performance and continue to be
immediately or a mixture of sealant and urine wouldused.
get pooled and give out a bad stench. University ofIn the past four years, the number of waterless urinals
Washington has since then uninstalled all the waterlesssold has doubled and sales continue to build up
urinals.strongly. James Krug is a happy man and
Falcon says that before putting a new cartridge, theconcentrating his efforts on other revolutionary
urinal has to be flushed with hot water to get rid of allinnovations in urinal technology.